Author Topic: Current Forum Poll (Read 1536 times)

CHARLIE · « **on:** June 21, 2004, 07:39:26 am »

That current forum poll on stem cell research is hard to answer without comments. There is more at issue than just a Yes or No. I would answer yes but with qualifications.

Rocky_J · « **Reply #1 on:** June 21, 2004, 12:10:35 pm »

It is an illogical and incomplete question which cannot be answered as asked by anyone who knows anything about the topic.

The drug companies and researchers are free to perform stem cell research to their heart's content. The sticking point is who will pay for it. All the campaigning about stem cell research is an attempt to get Federal dollars (read: tax dollars) to pay for it. Private industry can perform whatever research they want on their own nickel. If there is a good chance it will be profitable, private industry will do the research. But I do not believe Federal dollars should pay for private research that would otherwise be unprofitable and unproductive.

Stem cell research is NOT illegal (as some types would have you believe). It is simply not eligible for Federal funding.

Tom · « **Reply #2 on:** June 21, 2004, 12:20:19 pm »

I've understood that part of the problem with stem cell research is the "moral" argument over harvesting the stem cells. Also the insinuation that organ cells grown from them have some viable rights as a "being".

Even the private companies have problems with research when there are people using "moral" arguments to get them to quit. This world has people in it who are against anything. I heard, on TV, a self-righteous person say that "the researchers will perform abortions to get stem cells from the fetus'. " How does the world go ahead when there are people spouting doomsday rhetoric like that?

ARKANSAWYER · « **Reply #3 on:** June 22, 2004, 06:42:02 am »

Some time back I was at the Hospital to "do lunch" with my wife because I was sawing in the area. While waiting for her I was reading some mags there that I often do not read. In it was a story on the price of drugs and why federal dollars are needed to keep the cost down. When the drug company has to spend it's coin it has to pass the cost on to the consumer. But they were saying when Federal dollars were used the cost of the drugs would be kept down since the company was not out any thing and every one benifited. Sounded really good since my GrandMa's spend about $1 grand amonth together on drugs. Then the story went on to track one pill and how it was developed. It seems that this pill did not work as it was for a heart drug but they found that it did something else very well. It cost them about $150 million to come up with this pill and now they needed to sell it. So an ad campain started and the company spent like $257 million to let evey body know about this little blue pill that can change your world. Now there are several more like it and they all spend millions to let us know that they are out there. Drug companys spend millions on Doctors to get then to write the paper so we can buy the pill. Now here the deal. If the pill cost $20 each it would take about $0.50 to manufacture and the company would be out about$1.25 to get it on the shelf ready for sale and that includes development cost. The other $18.75 would be for Ads and profit so they can make more pills for us to take.
Now since I do not need the pill the ads are wasted on me just as are the millions spent to have Nike shoes on the feet of some basketball star. After all I wear steel toe boots 90% of the time. But should the day come when I need the blue pill I may think the $20 is not that bad. But how come GrandMa lived 75 years of her life with out hardly an asprin and now the Doc has convinced her she needs these pills in order to live? Coin, it all comes down to coin. Why spend your money to develop this or that when Uncle Sam will open the purse and then you can still make the profit or more and risk nothing.
As far back as written word we know that people have been slected breeding of animals and plants. Most of us know a prise bull when we see one or a pretty girl. As we have improved the way in which we can care and doctor people more and more live to reproduce and it is no longer the strongest who live. Do not get me wrong as I think all life is special and the work of God. Just the facts. The more I studied in college the more I learned and the more I became convinced that my fore fathers did not crawl out of some mud puddle. Life is special and has changed with the enviroment around it.
Now that we can mess with the building blocks of the structure of a being or plant we can really mess up. Caution should be taken with great care here. Some of this bio corn may produce a strain that we can not digest nor our live stock and insects have no use for it and can not kill it. This Kudzu Corn will overtake us and be our doom. This could be the end of grits.

Maybe federal money and regulations would guard aginst this. Maybe not. I know if I needed a kidney and they could grow a new one that would be really super. Not that long ago we were debating weither or not we should take part of a dead person and put it into a live one. Some times it worked and some times not. Mostly it works now. Do I have the correct answer? NO, but as we evolve as people we will keep messing with stuff. Now what they should be spending lots of money on is a DNA upgrade for oaks that grow square tall limbless trunks that add a growth ring every month and add 6 inches per year dib. Now that would be stem cell research!
ARKANSAWYER

CHARLIE · « **Reply #4 on:** June 22, 2004, 08:35:08 pm »

What grinds me is that the pill companies claim they have to charge so much to pay for the research and development. When the truth is, Universities usually do the research and development with government grants. What drives up the cost? I think it is all the multiple full page advertisements and TV advertising. I wish the federal government would pass a law not allowing the advertisement of prescription drugs except in medical journals or directly to the doctors. They are the ones that prescribe them.

Stan · « **Reply #5 on:** June 22, 2004, 08:53:24 pm »

What I know about the price of drugs, keeps my teeth short. The countries with socialized medicine, have a maximum they will pay for drugs. Guess who makes up the shortfall? You guessed it, the American consumer.

Patty · « **Reply #6 on:** June 23, 2004, 05:38:18 am »

"But how come GrandMa lived 75 years of her life with out hardly an asprin and now the Doc has convinced her she needs these pills in order to live? Coin, it all comes down to coin."

You hit the nail on the head there Arkansawyer. So many of the pills folks take are so unnecessary. Our society seems to think pills are magic and will make everything all better, and the doctors and drug companies are campaigning to make sure we continue in this downward spiral. Haytrader got the opportunity to witness recently just how many pills we shovel into old folks in the nursing homes, it is a crime. But nobody seems to mind because someone else is paying for it. So much of this would come to a screeching halt if the cost of all those drugs was coming directly out of pocket...not medicare, medicaid, or health insurance.

As far as the stem cell research....well I absolutely am vehemently against the government becoming more involved in the research. Anytime you resort to using the bodies of murdered babies for profit, you have a very morally corrupt society. I spoke to a friend about this. He has a spinal cord injury that has left him completely paralyzed, and if anyone could hope to benefit from this research it would be him. However he felt so strongly that this research was so wrong that he said he would rather remain paralyzed forever, than to think he somehow benefited from the death of an innocent baby.

CHARLIE · « **Reply #7 on:** June 23, 2004, 08:35:15 am »

I don't know much about Stem Cell research or how they obtain stem cells. I did read once that stem cells could be retrieved from umbilical cords. That is why I started this thread saying that I would say yes only with comments and reservations. I would only vote yes if the stem cells were retrieved from the umbilical cords from healthy birth of babies and with the permission of the parent(s).

Ron Wenrich · « **Reply #8 on:** June 23, 2004, 02:52:05 pm »

Britain has OKed stem cell research, but the stem cells are coming from frozen embryos. They only hold frozen embryos for 5 years. At that time, they are disposed. They figure it is just as good to give them to research.

I don't think the Brits have OKed cloning for stem cell research. Could be wrong.

DonE911 · « **Reply #9 on:** June 23, 2004, 03:46:45 pm »

Although this is not my opinion, I was sitting with a group of educated people ( Not to say I am not educated, just not in this area ) who were discussing stem cell research.

The general feeling was that no Federal Funding should be involved as compensation to private or public (Universities ect) researchers.

The fear was that one day soon if research is funded by government,that stem cell research will produce a cure for something that can not be cured or treated any other way. Once a proven cure has been discovered through stem cell research there will be an huge demand. Initially only the Super rich will be able to afford it, and the masses will eventually demand the cure at an affordable price. Where will all the stem cells come from?

Will there be a stem cell factory right next to the Nike factory in some third world country that is more interested in the $$ than the people who will be exploited?

I know this sounds stupid and the "morality" is certainly in question....

Seems to me, that the legality of research is not as big an issue as to what comes "after" research.

Someone will tinker with stem cells regardless.... because humans tinker with stuff until we find something useful... I think they new word for this is technology.

old3dogg · « **Reply #10 on:** June 24, 2004, 03:19:53 pm »

I just dont think that"we" have the right to play GOD.
If the big guy says its time to go than it is time to go.
Just my thought.

Rocky_J · « **Reply #11 on:** June 24, 2004, 04:43:30 pm »

old3dog,
I'm not trying to insult, but just pointing out a major inconsistency. Have you EVER taken any antibiotics to fight an infection? Have you taken meds for high blood pressure, or any other type of illness in your entire life? I'm assuming you have, since there might be only a couple hundred adults in the US that have never taken any medication or vaccination in their life. Well, unless you are one of those unfortuinate few, you have already crossed your self-imposed line of 'playing God'.

I believe that God gave us the ability to reason and think for the purpose of self-preservation. Man will continue to research and 'tinker' for as long as we exist. To stop and NOT do any research would be an insult to our Creator who endowed us with these gifts of reason and thinking.

But still, I do not believe tax dollars should be used for this purpose. Stem cell research is just as legal as any other type of research for whoever wishes to pay for it.

old3dogg · « **Reply #12 on:** June 24, 2004, 05:03:50 pm »

Rocky.
Dude!You cant insult me!Trust me.I will argue over anything.
The more I read about stem cell research the more it sounds to me like cloning.And cloning I feel,is wrong.
I am very thankful for medical research.If not for meds I wouldnt be here.
I just dont feel that mortel people should have the right to make people immortel.That Gods job.

Rocky_J · « **Reply #13 on:** June 24, 2004, 05:49:27 pm »

So, it was OK for researchers to use human and animal cells in order to develop the meds that you have taken in the past, but it is not ok for them to keep reaching into new areas of development for other new cures? At what point does it cross the line from 'research' to 'cloning'? And who said we were at that line now?

Again, no antagonism intended. Just trying to flesh out your argument so I understand.

old3dogg · « **Reply #14 on:** June 24, 2004, 06:32:08 pm »

Nah.I thinks its great that we get to defy our own moraitly these days.

ARKANSAWYER · « **Reply #15 on:** June 24, 2004, 07:12:20 pm »

Lets say that some body figures out how to get stem cells from an umbilical cord of a healthy baby which are just going to be desposed of. He or she comes up with a way to grow good organs or repair spinal cord injuries. They take a stem cell and some of your DNA and "Poof" your liver is ready to go. That would be a good deal. We do not need to abort a baby to get what we need to do this. Millions of umbilical cords are desposed of every day. There are babies born dead, for what ever reason, every day. All life is special and I would not wish that any one child be harmed for this. But there is an oppertunity for great things to come of this if done with the right morles.
One time I was electricuted and died. No heart beat, No sign of life. Just a limp, smoking body laying on the ground. Had GOD required my soul at that time nothing any man could have done would have put breath back into my body. This was over 20 years ago. Who has the right to play GOD at any thing. NO ONE! But due to the abilities GOD has given men I am alive today. My childern are healther and I can remember when few had open heart surgery. Now I know atleast 20 who have and 3 of them in my family. Where did this gift come from? Do you think that if GOD did not want us to be able to do this that he could not stop us? We are messing up the rest of the Earth why not our selves as well? Each time we come to a new cross roads like this we stop and ponder the weight of what we are doing. Some say NO and others just plow ahead. In time we sort it all out.
As for what GOD has to say on the matter I know of nothing. I know who and how to worship, how to talk, when to work, who to honor, faithfullness, No murdering,lying, stealing, gossiping, or coveting my neighbors ass. I know GODs Son was a good hand at healing and seemed to take great pleasure in it. I know I should take good care of my body and cause it no harm. Many things are told but it does not tell about such things as if I should pay $20 for the blue pill or not. Maybe I missed it.
Still I would like to see red oaks with square stems.
ARKANSAWYER

Bruce_A · « **Reply #16 on:** June 24, 2004, 07:33:07 pm »

Arkansawyer; Did that littlle bit of juice change your attitude for a while? I got a little jolt of 220 about twentyfive years ago and it totally changed my perspective for some time.

etat · « **Reply #17 on:** June 24, 2004, 10:37:34 pm »

The day they perfect that cloning I'm a going to do my best to be the first in line. Two of me exactly alike means I'd only have to work half as hard, and would have twice as much time to philosophize. And just think how much better off the world would be to have more than one of me, exactly alike.

Bruce_A · « **Reply #18 on:** June 25, 2004, 05:55:21 am »

CK; I took a look at my children, and deciced I didn't want to have anything to do with cloning.

ARKANSAWYER · « **Reply #19 on:** June 25, 2004, 09:22:45 pm »

Bruce,
I have no fear of death just growing old... It is hard to put your finger on it put many things are different. Since that time I can not wear metal or keep a watch on me that will work for very long.

I would be all for about 3 clones of me. Man what a deal. You think some sawing goes on this farm now! WoodMizer would like it as well as I would be wearing out some mills.
ARKANSAWYER

News:

Author Topic: Current Forum Poll (Read 1536 times)