Get your Forestry Forum Hats while they last!
0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.
There is a large group of loggers here in Pemberton that have worked closely with DFO for years building and maintaining hatcheries and other stream work as volunteersI'm trying to figure out if the first post was made out of ignorance,arrogance or wide eyed wonderment.
I missed tonights episode so I really do not know where you are coming from with that "guys so burned out from cutting trees" comment....But maybe I do not know what a "nice" or "protected" or "natural" forest truly is. Could you define that for me?
On the other hand, since I have grown up in this half of Oregon, it's not ignorance to say that I've never met a logger while hiking or camping.
It's not like they need to share tree-hugging, but somehow I get the feeling that their daily work influences their off-time activity and how they view forests.
But for all the time they spend leveling the forest, crushing the shrubs and mucking on the logging roads, how many of these loggers are hikers? Outdoorsmen that enjoy a nice forest?
Perhaps you should consider that loggers do not get "burned out" because they enjoy what they do and if they feel a need to relax, they can just shut off the saw or machine and just sit and enjoy for the moment all the beauty of the forest around. No need to take a walk, they are already where you long to be. But then again, I should not be telling everyone this because it may get to DanG crowded out there.
Jeff you sure nailed it with your comment of being offensive with the way the statement was worded with all the adjectives. Maybe it was not meant that way?? However, that's exactly how I took it whether it was meant that way or not. Before I even read to the bottom of the post.
i guess you missed the part where one of those ax men was talking about losing a good friend in a logging accident..maybe,because that tough guy was crying you missed it where he said he and his son took off for a couple of days and spend time in the woods just relaxing to try and get over the lose of a good friend.
For anyone who understands and has been around loggers, in general, do you find that they enjoy the outdoors and hiking as much as other folks in the general populace - do they like camping at Nehalem Bay, hiking Eagle Creek trail, walking around the Olympic National Forest?
I did not mean to rile you or offend you if I have. I'm just in agreement with Jeff's comment that maybe your statment could have been worded differently as it seems to infer that loggers have a very negative impact on the forest. That's literally how I took it whether it was intended or not. That's it!!
As a hypothesis, I would guess that whereas being in an office would make someone outdoors-hungry for a hiking trail, that working in a wooded area would leave someone less nature-hungry in regards to getting out and away.
mdvaden,I viewed your website and understand your need to get out into a real forest once in awhile.Your work demands a clean slate to begin and even though you apparently detest destruction of the natural enviroment,your business depends on it.
Perhaps asking if Loggers liked to hike after work is a valid question, it was the lead-in to the question, setting the premise that loggers had a "destruction mentality" that caused me to take a double-take.
That's basically true about the natural environment - but sort of dependent on how "natural environment" is defined.
...................But for all the time they spend leveling the forest, crushing the shrubs and mucking on the logging roads, how many of these loggers are hikers? Outdoorsmen that enjoy a nice forest?.............................................
There is nothing in the first post that deals with a destruction mentality.Maybe it's important for you to ask how you might extract "destruction mentality" from the opening post.Like if you read a much later reply of mine mentioning landscaping, if I were to describe landscaping at gutting-out old plants, digging holes and moving rock, how would that connote "destruction mentality".It's merely mentioning aspects of the work environment.[ .... ]In reviewing the opening post, I don't even think I implied a destruction environment. Plants and groundcover almost have to get stomped to harvest trees if it's going to be a full harvest of some acreage.To me, destruction is irreversible damage to the soil, streams and species, not clearing vegetation for harvesting.
There is nothing in the first post that deals with a destruction mentality.
describe landscaping at gutting-out old plants, digging holes and moving rock
But you can keep digging your way out of that original hole you put yourself in with this first post, as I think there are many good points that have been raised by yourself and several members in support of the loggers enjoying the demanding environment of their occupation. And we are getting to know you better, as well.
QuoteOn the other hand, since I have grown up in this half of Oregon, it's not ignorance to say that I've never met a logger while hiking or camping.Have you ever met a Vegas show girl while camping? A crab fisherman? A proctologist? A Mechanic? A salesman? How do you know? How many loggers out there wonder why they have never met an arborist camping? Probably none. Its a big world and if we're out and about enjoying it, we are probably not focused on the occupations of those around us or really even care. Loggers don't look like Paul Bunyan and probably don't wear suspenders and hard hats and don't wear labels that I know of other then those that others may try to paste on them. Unless you walked up to every person you ever saw in the woods while you were out and asked them what they did for a living, then how would you know. You might have been in the middle of a whole nest of em...QuoteIt's not like they need to share tree-hugging, but somehow I get the feeling that their daily work influences their off-time activity and how they view forests.I can see Paul's wondering why such a question. Whether it was meant to or not, it seems to infer a bunch. Its almost like you have loggers painted in your mind to be involved in some sort of destructive behavior that would negatively effect the things that you enjoy by comparisons in their work environment to a park setting. QuoteBut for all the time they spend leveling the forest, crushing the shrubs and mucking on the logging roads, how many of these loggers are hikers? Outdoorsmen that enjoy a nice forest?To someone that worked in the woods, the way you painted your question was offensive. The basic question without all the loaded adjectives would not be."Do guys that work in the woods everyday get tired of being in the woods and not enjoy it any longer?"That's my question above. I already know the answer because I've worked around and with hundreds of them.No. They don't get tired of it and most certainly enjoy it and appreciate it and understand that its ALL a nice forest.
routestep, thanks for the info. I would love to hike the AT and the Pacific Crest trails before I get too old.If I could get someone to buy a cedar mill, I could get started a lot sooner. The few times I have been on the AT I have seen quite a few hikers. Some trails just aren't hiked that much. I like the solitude.
What words we choose may form a picture in our own mind, but it is the picture it forms in the mind of the receiver that is important.
Testing New Bottom Sponsor Area